Update (Feb
2003): I discovered after I wrote this that Kiyosaki appears to
be a motivational writer, not the successful investor he claims to be.
His books were unsuccessful until he sold through Amway, which
sold them in sufficient volume to generate a "best-seller" label.
No name is ever given for "Rich Dad", and "Rich Dad" has been
trademarked. Attempts at discovering who "Rich Dad" was have been
unsuccessful. His real-estate stories are questionable as the
Phoenix court records do not indicate any activity by Kiyosaki.
In particular, some of his advice is questionable. For
example, he claims that he bought a foreclosure house for a small
amount of money down. At least in Texas, and I assume elsewhere,
you must write a check for the full amount upon winning the foreclosure
auction. A worthwhile web site is
The original review follows. Questionable or incorrect statements
have been colored grey.
At an early age, Kiyosaki wondered how he could get rich.
Fortunately, his friend Mike had a father who knew how to get
rich; the book is the summary of the lessons that Mike's father
("rich dad") taught them. Essentially the book says "buy things
that will make you money, not cost you money". In the first
chapter he describes the vicissitudes of the rat race: working
hard to get money, spending the money on a house, car, family, then
discovering that there is still not enough money and being forced to
work some more. In one sense this boils down to little more than
a spending problem,
but the
standard investment vehicles (notably mutual funds) offer a very slow
way of accumulating assets and most people know of no other options.
The solution, his rich dad says, is by buying things that will
make money.
Kiyosaki explicitly disputes the notion that working hard for a
corporation with good benefits and a secure job is a wise career
choice. Empirically, he says, it is not: the people who do
not need to work are not the diligent employees, but the owners.
What the owners possess provides them money for little or no
effort (rental properties, for example). The poor and middle
class, by contrast own things that cost them (houses and cars).
Thus they must continue working to continue paying the cost.
There is a short section on the implications of tax--a subject harped
on by investment books. The idea given here is simply that taxes
cost money which you'd rather not pay.
As a result, the rich create
corporations, which have a lower tax rate, but more importantly, allow
expenses to be paid before taxes, rather than afterwards, as is the
case with individuals.
A major theme of the book is that the rich take risks. The middle
class remain middle class because they are unwilling to take risks,
choosing instead the safe route: a corporation, a mutual fund.
Low risk, but low reward, and low reward means always needing to
work. The rich, Kiyosaki points out, literally create money, by
searching for opportunities and minimizing the risk by understanding
what they are doing. Along the same lines, he suggests that one
should pay yourself (i.e. invest in assets for yourself) first and pay
your bills second. Not that you default on your bills, but that
the pressing need will force you to become creative and somehow manage
to come up with the money.
Assorted principles from the book:
- The rich don't work for money
- Buy assets, not liabilities
- Mind your own business, not someone else's
- Work to learn, don't work for
money
- Buckminster Fuller's measure of wealth: the difference
between the income of your assets and the costs of your liabilities
- Assets: "businesses that do not require my presence;
stocks; bonds; mutual funds; income-generating real estate; notes
(IOUs); royalties from intellectual property; anything else that has a
value, produces income, or appreciates and has a ready market."
- Focus on developing management skills. The three most
important for a business are management of cash flow, management of
people, and management of personal time.
- 10 steps to awaken your financial genius:
- Need a strong reason. (For example: don't want to
work all my life, don't want the government to take it when I die.
Do want to travel the world when I'm young. Do want control
over my time and my life)
- Choose daily to be rich. (No excuses: too much
hassle, too busy, my husband does the finances) Invest in
education (seminars, books, etc.)
- Choose friends carefully:
seek people you can learn from (or learn what not to do)
- Master a formula and then learn a new one (learn to learn
quickly)
- Pay yourself first. (from The Richest Man in Babylon,
by George Classen)
- Pay your brokers well. Get a good broker and pay him:
he is supposed to provide you with good advice. (Naturally,
do not get a broker that is just a salesman)
- Try to get your money out as fast as possible (or better yet,
get something for free)
- Only assets buy luxuries
- Find someone who makes it look easy: having heroes causes
us to unconsciously think like them.
- Give and you shall receive, teach and you shall learn.
- Find someone who has done what you want to do.
- Take classes and buy tapes
- Make lots of offers (on
property). If you don't make an offer, you can't negotiate.
- Look for people who want to buy and then find someone who wants
to sell.
- If you want to get richer,
think bigger. (Ex: buy a larger chunk of land for your
friend and sell him only what he wanted, for a price that pays for all
of it. Or join together with a bunch of people to get a good
discount)
- Action always beats
inaction.
Ideas:
- tax lien certificates (low-risk, high yield)
- 1031 tax-deferred exchange (capital gains on sale of property are
not taxed if you buy another property with it)
These books were mentioned:
- Inc. and Grow Rich
- The Richest Man in Babylon, George Classen
- The 16 Percent Solution, Joel Moskowitz
- Beating the Street, Peter Lynch. (The principles of
finding value are not limited to stocks)
- Think and Grow Rich
- The Retirement Myth, Craig S. Karpel
- If You Want to be Rich and
Happy, Don't Go to School, Kiyosaki
Review: 9/10.
(Updated: 2/10)
Kiyosaki is no great writer, but the
concepts are concise, well-explained, and so useful that it is well
worth reading.
(Updated) It sounds like Kiyosaki is regurgitating other people's
ideas. The ideas in the first couple chapters are ok, take them
with a grain of salt, but the ideas for implementation are bad.
I'd give this about 7/10 for the good ideas, but the
misrepresentation and bad advice get a severe penalty. In short,
read the review, not the book.