Referee Report of Short Paper
Author:
Reviewer:
- If the paragraphs have not already been numbered, number
the paragraphs in the left margin, starting with the abstract,
- Underline the topic or point sentence of each paragraph. If
you cannot find the point sentence for any numbered paragraph, indicate
below: (a) the paragraph number and (b) what its point sentence should
be. Use the back of the sheet if necessary.
- Does the paper deliver what is promised in the abstract? Comment.
- Does the paper raise unanswered questions? Comment.
- Comment on the clarity of the paper.
Feel free to indicate ``typos" directly on your copy of the paper.
Return the paper with this report.
Your comments and
suggestions are appreciated.
[Previous]
[Writing Course Home Page]
To cite this page:
Referee Report of Short Paper
<http://www.physics.ohio-state.edu>
[]
Edited by: wilkins@mps.ohio-state.edu on