Referee Report of Short Paper



  1. If the paragraphs have not already been numbered, number the paragraphs in the left margin, starting with the abstract,
  2. Underline the topic or point sentence of each paragraph. If you cannot find the point sentence for any numbered paragraph, indicate below: (a) the paragraph number and (b) what its point sentence should be. Use the back of the sheet if necessary.
  3. Does the paper deliver what is promised in the abstract? Comment.
  4. Does the paper raise unanswered questions? Comment.
  5. Comment on the clarity of the paper.

Feel free to indicate ``typos" directly on your copy of the paper.

Return the paper with this report.

Your comments and suggestions are appreciated.
[Previous] [Writing Course Home Page]

To cite this page:
Referee Report of Short Paper

Edited by: on