Referee Report of 20-Minute Talk

Speaker:

Topic:

1. Briefly describe the main points of the talk. Be very specific.
2. Comment on quality of talk. With respect to the science, how did the speaker sustain your interest for the full 20 minutes? Were you lost or bored at any point?
3. Comment on clarity of the viewgraphs. Did you miss any important point because it was not on a viewgraph? What figures confused you?
4. Comment on organization of the material. Be specific. Did the speaker
   • clearly indicate the plan of the talk in the introduction ?
   • clearly lead you from one main point to the next in the development ?
   • provide a concise summary, putting the talk in a broader context in the conclusion ?
5. Additional comments: For example, articulation, eye contact, hand gestures

Please put your name here. ____________________