We investigate the low energy dynamics of ${\cal N}=1$ supersymmetric $SO(N)$ gauge theories with a single symmetric tensor matter field. These theories exhibit non-trivial matching of global 't Hooft anomalies at the origin of moduli space. We argue that their quantum moduli spaces possess distinct Higgs and confining branches which touch at the origin in an interacting nonabelian Coulomb phase. The matching of anomalies between microscopic degrees of freedom and colorless moduli therefore appears to be coincidental. A formal mathematical relation between the $SO(N)$ model and an analogous $Sp(2N)$ theory with a single antisymmetric matter field provides an explanation for the anomaly matching coincidence.